Site Meter Hogwarts Herald » Blog Archive » Snape. Good or Evil?

Snape. Good or Evil?

by Maddy

severussnape.jpgScholastic.com has been posting questions (speculations) about the final Harry Potter book. They’re on to question #5 (of seven) - but I’m going to back track to question #2 (Tiny Treasury has already asked question #1).

Is Snape good or evil?

My answer: good. I really believe it. I think that most of his nastiness comes from the way he was treated as a child/adolescent - and that he turned to the “dark side” in his youth because he saw no other way. But he must be good at heart, so else I don’t believe that Dumbledore would have brought him in as a teacher - if her really believed that he was as “far gone” as, say, Lucius Malfoy, then I don’t think he would have allowed him to teach anything.

, ,


Posted in General, Snape, Theories on June 12th, 2007

Link to this Entry

Recent Posts

Related Posts

3 Responses to “Snape. Good or Evil?”

  1. DaveP Says:
    June 12th, 2007 at 10:43 am

    I think he’ll end up being good, and that would be thr right thing to do for the last book. The whole series has shown him in a bad light, but with flashes of good, and to have him save the day at the end would be the best outcome.

  2. Brick Says:
    June 14th, 2007 at 2:13 pm

    I agree, he’ll end up good. Just re-read JK interviews. In one, an audience member asked about Snape’s “redemptive pattern”, and she was taken aback. I wonder what redemptive act he’ll do?

  3. Jennifer Springer Says:
    June 20th, 2007 at 11:25 pm

    Snape has to be good or I’ll cry ;) He is seriously though my very favorite character. I think that of all of them he is the most complex and the most human!

Leave a Reply


About Hogwarts Herald

Hogwarts Herald is here to document the press surrounding all things Harry Potter.

Hogwarts Herald Author(s)
    » Cindy-Crouch

NAVIGATE

LINKS

CATEGORIES

TOP COMMENTERS

RECENT COMMENTS

SUBSCRIBE

ARCHIVES

Books & Writing Channel Posts

  • Writing and Inspiration
    “One of the illusions of life is that the present hour is not the critical, decisive hour. Write it on your heart that every day is the best day of the year.” Ralph Waldo Emerson If you [...]
  • The 99th Monkey by Eliezer Sobel - Author Virtual Book Tour
    Join Eliezer Sobel, author of the memoir, The 99th Monkey: A Spiritual Journalist's Misadventures with Gurus, Messiahs, Sex, Psychedelics, and Other Consciousness-Raising Adventures (Santa Monica [...]
  • `Twilight' Steps Up When `Harry Potter' Gets Delayed
    Harry Potter fans will have to wait almost another year before they can see the sixth movie, Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince. Originally scheduled for a theater release date of November 21, [...]
  • A Book by Any Other Name - Beauty
    Welcome to this week’s A Book By Any Other Name! The game works like this: Each week I will choose a word and offer a few titles that I’ve come up with containing that word in the title. Then [...]
  • Scribe Notes
    FictionScribe: Hey JM. JM: Hiya. What’s up? FS: Well, you’ve been slacking a bit on posting lately. I’m not really feeling the love. JM: If it makes you feel better, I’ve been [...]
  • Weekend Reading: Angela Booth
    From the Web: A fantastic article by Angela Booth that explains what I've been pondering in a fuzzy kind of way: Write More, Write Faster at Freelance Writing. Her advice includes creating process [...]
  • Kate Jacobs: She Has a Way With Women Characters
    I hate spending money on hardback books: they are twice the price as paperbacks and take up more room on my shelves. Unfortunately, publishers have got in the habit of only releasing a hard copy for [...]
  • Fundamentals: Write, Write, Write Again
    1. Create. 2. Refill. 3. Offer. So here I am, sitting in my office at home, or, somedays, trying to get comfortable on that hard chair at the cafe. I pull up my email, read through messages, [...]
  • I'm Watching You by Mary Burton - Book Review
    Lindsay O’Neil has dedicated her life to helping women and their children escape from domestic abuse situations. She is a hero to many, and more than that, she is a friend. When someone decides to [...]
  • Interview with Historical Fiction Author Suzanne Woods Fisher
    Today we are joined by historical fiction author Suzanne Woods Fisher who is on virtual tour this month with her book Copper Fire. If you have any questions or comments, please don't be shy. :) Say [...]

 

Hot Off The Press

  • Whole Heap O' Gay Weddings
    So you've probably heard this by now but Ellen Degeneres and girlfriend Portia de Rossi were wed in a ceremony at their Beverly Hills home Saturday night. Ellen kept it real...real small by only [...]
  • Oils to Help Cure Some Common Ailments (A)
    1. For Acne: • Cedarwood can be use for its antiseptic and astringent properties. • Try patchouli. • Apple cider vinegar mixed with tea tree oil can be applied right on the breakout. • [...]
  • Retcon Patrol 1-11: "Family Day" Part 3
    Today we continue our search for inconsistent or comment-worthy moments in the Brothers & Sisters first season with a look at the third part of Episode 11. Read Part 1 and Part 2 if you need to catch [...]
  • Interview With a Producer
    Good morning, everyone! Well, so far no storm has wrecked havoc like the Houseiwves had to deal with so, here I am! And I’ve got something cool to share. Writer/Producer Jeff Greenstein recently [...]
  • Why Recycle?
    Why recycle? It’s one of the “greenest” things you can do. When you recycle a plastic bottle: It keeps that item out of the landfill, or trash heap, or ocean; It allows [...]
  • Massaro Speaks on Strip Club Appearance, Eugene Update
    Ashley Massaro posted on her Myspace on her Strip Club appearance. Monday, August 18, 2008 Strip Clubs, Rain, Moving and Casinos What up yall, damn its been awhile, sorry I was away so [...]
  • Double-Dig to Improve Soil Health
    Double digging is a great way to improve nutrients and the overall health of your soil. Double digging loosens soil down to a depth of 18 inches. Why is healthy soil important, it increases [...]
  • The Terrell Owens (Circa 2005) Effect: Five Receivers To Avoid
    We have all over-drafted a player a year too late, a year too early, under the wrong circumstances and sometimes we were just lacking the appropriate information. These are five players to avoid [...]
  • Writing and Inspiration
    “One of the illusions of life is that the present hour is not the critical, decisive hour. Write it on your heart that every day is the best day of the year.” Ralph Waldo Emerson If you [...]
  • Date Set for Hulk Hogan’s ‘Celebrity Championship Wrestling’
    Hulk Hogan’s ‘Celebrity Championship Wrestling’ will premier on CMT on Saturday, October 18 at 8:00 PM ET. The series will feature 8 1-hour episodes where Celebrities are trained to have a [...]